Tuesday , May 24 2016
Breaking News
Home / Tech Updates / Racketeering claims against patent troll rejected,Wi-Fi patent

Racketeering claims against patent troll rejected,Wi-Fi patent


Wi-Fi patent

A federal judge has dismissed legal claims filed by a trio of networking companies against a licensing company they accused of illegally demanding Wi-Fi patent licensing fees from bakeries, hotels, cafes, and other businesses.

Cisco Systems, Motorola Solutions, and Netgear filed a complaint last year against Innovatio IP Ventures, which has sued about 20 businesses for patent infringement because they had purchased and were using Wi-Fi equipment made by the plaintiffs. The complaint alleged that the patent assertion entity sent 8,000 threatening letters to business in all 50 states in an effort “to defraud and extort illegal fees” and thus violated federal antiracketeering laws.

Also known as patent trolls, PAEs are created to extract licensing fees from other companies rather than make products based on the patents.

However, in a ruling issued late Monday, U.S. District Judge James Holderman in Chicago held that Innovatio’s petitioning activity was protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. If true, the allegations — made by — “do not establish that Innovatio’s licensing campaign alleging infringement of the Innovatio patents is a sham,” Holderman said in a 34-page ruling.

“It is enough for now to determine that Innovatio at least has a plausible argument that its infringement claims are still viable,” Judge Holderman wrote. Despite plaintiffs’ arguments that Innovatio’s claims were “baseless,” Holderman said “the licensing campaign is therefore not a sham.”

The judge left in tact claims against Innovatio that allege breach of contract in regards to agreements the companies made with previous holders of the patents.

The percentage of patent infringement lawsuits filed PAEs has increased dramatically in the past couple of years. According to a study conducted last year by a patent law professor in California, about 62 percent of all patent lawsuits filed in 2012 up to December 1 were brought by PAEs. In 2011, about 45 percent of patent lawsuits were filed by patent trolls, while in 2010, about 29 percent of all patent infringement lawsuits were filed by PAEs.




  1. hi everyone

    before I download this item from the web

    Among the finest to be aware what is that this


    thanks alot

  2. hi buddies help me key to configure a ‘cisco’ router

  3. without ‘cisco’ Home web page

  4. Wendell Grandchild


    Im confusing about this ,i’ve the ‘cisco’ 1841 router which i wish to connect to the web Ok.

    My modem has this ip 255.255.255. (the modem is connected right to the wall phone socket)

    My local network has 3 pc computer systems with this particular ip (Hewlett packard laptop)

    (DELL desk)

    DELL desk)

    My router has two connects FAST ETHERNET /1 linked to (modem)

    FAST ETHERNET / linked to 10.10.1 (local network)

    How do i obtain the 3 computer systems attached to the internet ? I understand it isn’t tougher for somebody that

    is aware of ‘cisco’ hubs .

    I m utilizing a simple network no gateways ,no dns servers or some factor like this .

    Sorry for that bad british ,thanks ahead of time for each help

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *